Files

11 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Power saving on a solar repeater — what it costs, measured

Everything here was measured on the deployment hardware (SenseCAP Solar Node P1-Pro, nRF52840 + SX1262 + L76K) on 2026-08-05/06 with tools/power_ab.py, not taken from a datasheet. Numbers are input current on the 5 V USB side; the delta between two states is what the paired design measures, and that is what these figures are.

The order that matters

lever measured verdict
GPS running continuously 46.0 mA (spread 43.7-47.5) gps duty recovers 42-45 of it
BLE advertising + Bluefruit's blinking LED see below defaults changed, LED off, 1 s interval
powersaving on (MCU light sleep) ~1 mA, not separable from zero keep it on (free), but it is not a lever
RX duty cycle (set radio.rxps, from EasySkyMesh) ~2.3 mA at max (XIAO, 12. 11. 2026) no on a live node: -16 % received and a TX stall on mast-three, see below
radio.rxgain off ~0.7 mA no — 1-3 dB of sensitivity is what a mast node is for
FEM LNA control n/a SenseCap has no FEM, only an RXEN switch

A whole node in the shipping configuration, with the battery charged and GPS duty-cycled, sits at ~24 mA. Continuous GPS alone would nearly triple that.

GPS is the whole game

The receiver on this board draws 46 mA, and a mast repeater runs GPS for one reason only: the RTC is volatile, and a node whose clock is wrong has its replies dropped by clients. It does not need a continuous fix — it needs the clock set.

GPS is no longer the only way to get that (since 7. 8. 2026 a node starts at its build epoch and any attached host sets it — see docs/cli_commands.md under time). A reboot still throws the clock back to the build epoch: carrying it across one in retained RAM was tried and measured not to work, because the bootloader's stack owns the top of RAM. GPS is still what makes a mast node's clock absolutely right months after the flash, with nobody there to set it, so this reasoning stands for anything on a mast. What changed is that a node without GPS is no longer stuck in 2024.

gps duty (gps_enabled == 2, so no prefs-layout change) powers the receiver only around a sync, once a day (until 11/2026 every 30 minutes, the cadence gps on re-syncs at). The LF crystal is ±20 ppm plus ~40 ppm at −10 °C, so a day costs ~5 s of clock — far below what the mesh notices — and a reboot syncs at once anyway. Verified on hardware in both paths (with the old 30 min / 1 h timers):

  • with sky (mast-three): duty, asleep, fix, 7 sats — got a fix, set the clock, cut power to the receiver;
  • without (indoors, bench-rpt): awake for exactly 300 s (GPS_DUTY_MAX_AWAKE_SECS), then asleep with an hourly retry, so a blocked sky cannot turn duty mode back into "always on".

Worst case (fix never obtained) still saves 42 mA; a normal 30 s fix saves 45. Going from 30 min to 24 h saves another 0.25–0.75 mA (hot vs. warm start, not measured per window), and the retry from 1 h to 6 h takes a node whose dome is under snow from 3.8 mA (300 s at 46 mA hourly) to 0.64 mA. Knobs: GPS_DUTY_SYNC_INTERVAL_SECS (86400), GPS_DUTY_MAX_AWAKE_SECS (300), GPS_DUTY_RETRY_SECS (21600).

Upstream later (v1.18 dev, 11/2026) added its own gps period <s>. It is not a replacement: a periodic acquisition has no timeout until the first fix ever, so the indoor case above would stay at 46 mA for good. gps duty sets the period to 0, and gps on / gps off leave duty mode.

One visible side effect: querySensors() only adds the GPS channel to telemetry while the receiver is powered, so a duty-cycled node reports position in telemetry only during its sync windows (well under 1 % of the time). What a repeater advertises is unaffected — that comes from prefs via set advert.loc prefs (formerly gps advert prefs) — and node_lat/lon keep the last fix. Confirmed in the field: mast-three's scrape now carries voltage/temperature/humidity and no gps field.

BLE: two defaults that were quietly expensive

  • The blinking LED. Bluefruit drives LED_BLUE while advertising and holds it on while connected. On SenseCap Solar that pin is 12 — the same pin as P_LORA_TX_LED, so a sealed mast node spent solar charge blinking an LED nobody can see, and the LoRa TX indicator lied as a bonus. RPT_BLE_CONN_LED now defaults to 0.
  • The advertising rate. Upstream leaves the slow interval at 244 units = 152.5 ms, i.e. three channels ~6.5 times a second, forever. RPT_BLE_ADV_SLOW now defaults to 1600 = 1 s; the first RPT_BLE_ADV_FAST_SECS (30) after boot or disconnect stay fast so discovery is still immediate when someone is looking.

Bench boards keep both upstream behaviours (-D RPT_BLE_CONN_LED=1, -D RPT_BLE_ADV_SLOW=244 in xiao_analyzer): on a desk the blinking LED is the "this thing is alive" indicator.

ble off remains the big BLE lever for a deployed node, but the deployment rule stands: ship with BLE on, verify the node on site, and only then turn it off over the mesh — otherwise a node that does not come up has no way in.

RX duty cycle (rxps)

Ported from EasySkyMesh PowerSaving v18 behind -D WITH_RX_POWERSAVING (the public releases have it), SX1262 only, off until set. The radio listens in short windows and sleeps between them, staying awake through a packet once it hears a preamble; after three failed arms it falls back to continuous RX by itself. Commands: docs/cli_commands.md, radio.rxps.

Measured 12. 11. 2026 on a XIAO nRF52840 + Wio-SX1262 (not the SenseCAP of the rest of this page), bench preset 866.5 MHz / SF8 / BW62.5, fed at 5 V through an INA226 (10 mOhm) read every 5 s; the only other load was a UC96 on the XIAO's USB port. A/B/A/B, 15 min cells, the first 2 min of each dropped:

cell rxps mean median
1 off 33.84 mA 32.2 mA
2 max 31.31 mA 30.5 mA
3 off 33.53 mA 32.5 mA
4 max 31.36 mA 30.3 mA

max (level 8) against the mean of its neighbours: -2.4 / -2.2 mA, pooled -2.35 mA (medians -1.95 mA); off vs off differs by 0.3 mA, max vs max by 0.05 mA. That is the radio's share, so it carries over to other SX1262 boards in absolute terms; the 33 mA base is this bench (meter, BLE advertising), not a node. Behind the XIAO's linear regulator the battery sees the same current: ~7-8 mW at 3.3 V.

Reception: a 3-board zero-hop matrix (x1, x3, x4; rxps switched on x1 and x4, x3 the reference with rxps off; 20 rounds per phase, each link witnessed by another board), run twice -- on the development build, then repeated on the public release v1.18.0+tth.20261112 (ver v1.18.0-tthd4afea1):

phase development build public release together
rxps off 0/120 1/120 1/240
on (level 3) 1/120 2/120 3/240
max (level 8) 0/120 0/120 0/240

rxps stayed armed throughout, no error counts. Single losses happen with rxps off as well, and of the three at level 3 one was on x3, which had rxps off: the bench shows no degradation at any level. Not measured: mixed SF/preamble senders, a busy live mesh. On a mast, where 2 mA of ~24 is not the problem, leave it off.

On the live mesh it failed (mast-three, 14. 11. 2026, max). Against ob1 as the reference for the hour-to-hour traffic, the node received ~16 % fewer packets (2.08 vs 2.47 per ob1 packet) with ~30 % more recv_errors, and within two hours of switching it on it stopped transmitting altogether: sent frozen, queue full (32), no tx_start_fail/tx_timeout, RX still counting -- so no adverts and no replies to an admin login, for 6+ hours. radiostat showed irq=0x0014 (preamble + header valid, no RX done). set radio.rxps off did NOT bring TX back; a reboot did. The mechanism is not proven, and the radio silence watchdog cannot see it (it watches RX only). Do not enable rxps on a node that has to answer.

MCU sleep

powersaving on makes the nRF52 wait in WFE between events (it wakes on any interrupt, including LoRa DIO1). Upstream ships it off, and it was missing from our provisioning, so every node built from that file ran the core at 64 MHz around the clock. It is now in our provisioning file.

But it buys about 1 mA, not the 3-4 that seemed obvious. Measured with GPS held off so its sync windows could not pollute the cells: paired estimate -0.96 mA over three pairs, spread -1.97 to +0.07, against a measured cell-to-cell repeatability of 1.16 mA — i.e. the effect is the same size as this rig's noise and cannot be told from zero. That fits the mechanism: the loop still polls the SX1262 over SPI on every pass and the SoftDevice wakes the core for each advertising event, so there is not much idle left to sleep through. Keep it on (it is free and cannot hurt), but do not budget for it.

Blocking the loop task instead of waiting for an event (so that FreeRTOS can sleep tickless) changes nothing either: delay(10) against sd_app_evt_wait(), XIAO x4, A/B/A/B 30 min cells (14. 11. 2026): paired difference 0.04 mA, cell repeatability 0.1-0.4 mA. The tick wakeups are not where the current goes.

One fork-specific fix goes with it: the sleep is also held off while the BLE console still has queued output (bleTxPending()), because on the observer node a half-drained rxlog/pktlog page would otherwise wait for the next connection event — the bridge drains those on a 2-minute duty cycle, so a slower drain directly costs collected frames.

Measuring this yourself — two traps

  1. A solar node measured on its USB side measures the CHARGER. With a charging cell the meter reads 500-700 mA, pulsing, and the node's own tens of mA ride on top of a drifting number. Wait for the charge to finish (it fell 0.71 → 0.53 → 0.22 → 0.05 A over about an hour here) or the numbers are fiction. There is no INA226 on this board to cross-check with — the i2c command reports nothing at all on the only bus the variant has — on three separate P1-Pro units (bench-rpt, mast-rpt-two, tth-mast-repeater-one), against a sensor table that expects 38 76 70 44 5C 42 40 41 5A 29 77. So it is the board, not one dead part, and the cross-check for a power measurement has to be a second board.
  2. With gps duty enabled you cannot measure anything under ~5 mA. A sync window lands in a random cell and adds ~17 mA to a 10-minute average (seen: 40.9 mA against 24.1-24.5 in its neighbours). Put gps off in every cell of such a run and restore gps duty afterwards.

See tools/power_ab.py --help for the alternating-cell design that makes these deltas trustworthy in the first place.